ACCESS WITHOUT ASSIMILATION: I REFUSE TO AUDITION FOR A ROOM I CAN AFFORD TO ENTER

ACCESS WITHOUT ASSIMILATION: I REFUSE TO AUDITION FOR A ROOM I CAN AFFORD TO ENTER

I do declare, I found myself in a bit of a quandary while in Wisconsin. There I was, minding my own beautifully moisturized business, when a powerful thirst came over me — a hankering, if you will, for a little vino. And lo and behold, the universe presented me with a winery. Pretty as a postcard. Practically curtsying at me from across the lawn.

And yet — and this is the part where I clutch my pearls and my car keys at the same time — I never made it past the parking lot.

But let me back up, because the quandary started before the wine did.

I have been Black long enough to know there are buildings you enter with your feet and buildings you enter with your entire nervous system. Nobody has to say a single blessed thing to you. There doesn't need to be a sign, a sneer, a Confederate flag waving beside the hydrangeas or a woman clutching her handbag like you've arrived specifically to steal a nine-year-old Coach purse. Sometimes absolutely nothing happens. You simply look around and something inside you says, Mmmm. Let me assess this situation before I take my coat off.

So there I was in Wisconsin, near the Illinois border, having stumbled upon Timber Hill Winery. The surrounding area was beautiful, manicured and unmistakably affluent. Not old-money Newport affluent, either. This was newer money, newer houses, enormous lawns, pristine developments and the unmistakable feeling that everybody's garage contained equipment with its own financing plan. It was lovely. It was also the kind of area where I could reasonably assume I was not going to wander into the annual meeting of the Congressional Black Caucus.

The winery itself was a whole situation — beautiful — so naturally I looked at the menu. Seven dollars for a glass of wine and eighteen dollars for a bottle. Eighteen dollars. I stared at that price like it had personally insulted my grandmother, because apparently Wisconsin had failed to receive the memorandum explaining that wine cannot possibly be sophisticated unless somebody charges $47 for it and tells you the grapes experienced emotional adversity. At eighteen dollars a bottle, I was prepared to become a temporary Wisconsin aristocrat. I had already selected my imaginary title.

We drove over. We arrived. I looked around. I took photographs.

And then I sat my ass in the car.

WHEN INSTINCT AND DISCOMFORT START WEARING THE SAME COAT

Now, let the record show: nobody bothered me at Timber Hill. Nobody insulted me, followed me, refused me service or asked what I was doing there. Nobody had the opportunity — because I never gave them one. I never went inside. Something about the environment made me hesitate, and I listened to it. At the time, that seemed perfectly reasonable. What bothered me came later, when I realized I couldn't explain precisely what I had felt.

Was I detecting something genuinely wrong, or was I uncomfortable because I had entered an affluent environment where I didn't expect to see many people who looked like me? Those are not the same thing, and pretending they are doesn't help anybody. Black people have survived quite a bit by learning to read rooms before the room bothered to introduce itself. I have no intention of throwing that instinct away in the name of personal growth, Chardonnay or proving that I can mingle with Republicans.

But instinct deserves interrogation too, sweetheart. Even the good instincts. Especially the good ones.

That is where this idea of access without assimilation began for me. I started thinking about all the rooms we might never enter because we have already imagined what will happen once we do. Sometimes that imagination is informed by experience. Sometimes it is informed by history. Sometimes it is completely justified. But sometimes the possibility of rejection becomes so familiar that nobody actually has to reject us anymore. We quietly handle the administrative work ourselves.

Now that is some efficient discrimination. They don't even have to lift a finger. We pencil ourselves out of the guest list with a smile.

I AM NOT TRYING TO "ENTER HIGH SOCIETY"

There is a peculiar genre of advice online telling people where to go if they want to "enter high society." Luxury watch boutiques. Polo matches. Art galleries. Wine tastings. Country clubs. Yacht clubs. Five-star hotel lobbies. Apparently, if I position myself beside enough wealthy people, eventually somebody will become disoriented and put me in the will.

I have checked. This is not a reliable financial strategy. I ran the numbers twice.

There is, however, one intelligent idea buried underneath all that aspirational foolishness: opportunity has geography. People form relationships through repeated proximity. Industries develop their own gathering places. Artists congregate somewhere. Investors congregate somewhere. Writers, architects, collectors, entrepreneurs, academics and people with specialized knowledge congregate somewhere. If I never leave the environments I already understand, I will continue meeting variations of people I already know and encountering information I could have found without leaving the house.

That interests me far more than "high society." I don't want proximity to rich people for the sake of proximity to rich people. Money does not automatically make someone fascinating. I've met poor people who could hold a room for three hours and people with enormous bank accounts who could bore wallpaper off the wall. I want access to experiences, information, conversations and environments that enlarge my world.

And I am absolutely not changing personalities to get them. I am not a software update.

ACCESS WITHOUT ASSIMILATION MEANS I DON'T NEED A COSTUME

I don't need to acquire an imaginary boarding-school accent before entering an art gallery. I don't need to purchase a Hermès scarf on Tuesday and develop a passionate interest in polo by Thursday. I don't need to know which fork was personally blessed by the Duke of Something-or-Other. I need basic cultural literacy, appropriate manners and a legitimate reason for being there. The rest is theater, and I wasn't cast. Not even in the ensemble.

The distinction I've finally made is that access and belonging are not the same thing. I don't belong to the Louvre; I visit it. I don't belong to a winery; I drink there. I don't belong to a luxury hotel lobby, but if its bar is open to the public, I can sit down, order something with a lemon twist and admire the furniture like everybody else. I can appreciate the chandelier without asking the chandelier to validate my existence.

We put tremendous psychological weight on the word belonging. Sometimes I don't need to belong. Sometimes I just need to go inside. If I require myself to feel completely comfortable before experiencing anything unfamiliar, I have built a marvelous little prison and thoughtfully installed the lock from the inside. And decorated it, too. With great taste. Because I contain multitudes, but I refuse to contain myself.

Comfort often comes after access, not before it. The door opens first. The shoulders drop later.

SO I DEVELOPED THREE ANCHORS

The next time I enter an unfamiliar environment, I am taking three things with me: a purpose, a little knowledge and one good question. That is enough. I don't need a networking strategy tucked into my brassiere.

The purpose is simple. I know why I'm there. If I'm at a winery, I'm tasting wine. If I'm at a gallery, I'm seeing an exhibition. If I'm attending an author event, I'm interested in the book. If I'm sitting in a historic hotel bar, I'm having a cocktail and being nosy about the architecture. Having a purpose stops that ridiculous internal audition where you walk into a room and immediately begin wondering whether everyone else thinks you should be there. Nobody's holding auditions. I checked the call board.

Then I learn one thing before I arrive. Not everything. I do not need to become a sommelier overnight because somebody poured fermented grapes into a long-stemmed glass. I can learn what the winery grows. I can read about the artist whose work I'm about to see. I can look up the history of the hotel. Ten minutes of genuine curiosity gives me enough context to stop feeling like I've accidentally wandered into somebody else's wedding reception. And nobody wants to be at somebody else's wedding reception. Not even the guests.

Finally, I carry one real question. "Which wine here is most characteristic of this region?" "Is this artist local?" "Was this building always a hotel?" Questions work because people generally enjoy talking about things they know. Suddenly I am participating in the environment instead of standing against a wall pretending to check an important email from absolutely nobody. We have all done it. The phone was off. The email was fictional. The wall was load-bearing. So were we.

I ALSO NEED TO STOP CALLING EVERYTHING NETWORKING

Networking has become one of those words that makes otherwise normal adults behave like malfunctioning sales representatives. People enter a room and immediately begin mentally sorting everybody into categories: useful, not useful, powerful, not powerful, connected, not connected. I find this exhausting. I did not get dressed for this.

I am not going to a wine tasting hunting for a millionaire. I am going because I like wine. If I repeatedly enter interesting environments because I am genuinely interested in what happens there, my social world will naturally become larger. Eventually I recognize somebody. Somebody recognizes me. We continue a conversation from the previous event. Someone mentions another exhibition, another restaurant, another lecture or another place worth visiting. Relationships develop through familiarity, not because I cornered somebody beside the hors d'oeuvres and delivered my elevator pitch while they desperately searched for an exit.

That is the part those "25 Places to Meet Wealthy People" lists usually miss. The room isn't magic. Repeated presence is. Curiosity is. Conversation is. Being an interesting person who is actually interested in other people certainly doesn't hurt either. Being interesting and being interested — that combination is practically a skeleton key.

SOME ROOMS AREN'T WORTH THE TROUBLE

Access without assimilation does not mean forcing myself into every exclusive environment just because I technically can. Some places are easy entry points because the activity gives everyone a reason to be there: museums, galleries, author talks, wine tastings, cultural events, hotel bars, public lectures, design showcases and ticketed charity events. I like those rooms because there is already something to discuss besides ourselves. A shared subject is a marvelous chaperone.

Other spaces require more homework. Golf events, polo matches, marina events, luxury boutiques and certain private wellness spaces have more unwritten rules. Fine. I can learn the rules. Half of intimidation is missing information. Once I know the dress code, reservation policy, cost and what people actually do when they get there, much of the mystery disappears. And mystery, once you turn on the lights, is usually just a coat rack.

Then there are genuinely private clubs whose entire business model is essentially, You cannot come in unless we say so. Wonderful. Enjoy yourselves. I am not spending Thursday afternoon emotionally wrestling with a velvet rope. If I receive an authentic invitation and want to attend, I will. Otherwise, I have books to read and wine that costs eighteen dollars a bottle. Eighteen. Wisconsin understood the assignment.

THE TWENTY-MINUTE RULE I WISH I HAD USED IN WISCONSIN

If I could replay that afternoon at Timber Hill, I wouldn't force myself to stay. I would simply give myself twenty minutes. I would get out of the car, walk inside, order the seven-dollar glass of wine and sit somewhere comfortable. Then I would observe. I would let the room make its case before I rendered my verdict.

Twenty minutes is long enough for my nervous system to collect actual information. Maybe the bartender is lovely. Maybe nobody gives a damn that I'm there — a possibility my imagination had not bothered to include in its little dramatization. Maybe another woman asks what I'm drinking and ten minutes later we're discussing wineries like old friends. My shoulders come down and I realize the threat wasn't the room; it was unfamiliarity wearing a disguise.

Or perhaps the feeling doesn't disappear. Maybe the service changes temperature. Maybe I notice that I'm being watched differently. Maybe nothing dramatic happens, but enough little things accumulate that I decide I don't want to spend another dollar there. Then I leave. Quietly, with my dignity tucked under my arm like a good purse.

That is the part I refuse to surrender. Access without assimilation also means access without captivity. I don't owe any room my presence merely because I worked up the nerve to enter it. I am not on retainer.

THE MOST IMPORTANT RECEIPT IS THE ONE I BRING HOME

This experience changed the question for me. I am no longer particularly interested in asking, Do these people think I belong here? That puts entirely too much authority in the hands of strangers who may themselves be idiots. Plenty of them are. Idiots have memberships too.

My question is different now: Does this place belong in my life?

Did I enjoy myself? Did I learn something? Was I treated well? Did I meet someone interesting? Did I discover something I want to understand better? Did I feel myself shrinking, performing or modifying who I was because I thought the room required it? Did my initial discomfort disappear once I had actual information, or did the environment give me legitimate reasons not to return?

Those questions put the decision back where it belongs.

With me. Where it has been the whole time, honestly. I was just letting strangers hold the pen.

I still think about that Wisconsin winery and the beautiful afternoon sitting outside my car window like a wine-adjacent ghost. I don't regret listening to myself. I regret not investigating what myself was saying. There is an enormous difference. One is wisdom. The other is just an unfinished conversation.

So the next unfamiliar room gets a fair hearing. I will get out of the car. I will walk through the door. I will order the wine — perhaps even the bottle, because eighteen dollars. I will observe. I will enjoy myself if there is something worth enjoying, and I will leave if there isn't. No quandary required. No pearls to clutch. Just me, a glass, and a perfectly good chair with my name not on it, which is precisely the point.

I am not auditioning for high society. I am not trying to become acceptable to people with more money than I have. I am not exchanging myself for admission. No refunds, no exchanges, no alterations.

I am expanding the geography of my own life.

And if the room cannot accommodate me without requiring an edited version of me, then darling, the room has failed the interview. And I do believe we were done here.

— Pepper Saint Clair

THE PROPER POUR: THE OPEN DOOR

After all that talk about walking through doors, I believe we have earned a drink.

And no, I will not be calling it The Assimilation. I have standards.

This one is The Open Door, because that is precisely what I intend to give unfamiliar rooms from now on: an opening. Not blind trust. Not automatic suspicion. Not a personality transplant performed beside the coat check. Just an opportunity to show me what they are before I decide whether I intend to stay.

The drink should behave accordingly. Champagne gives us the occasion, cognac gives it enough backbone not to become precious, elderflower brings something elegant to the proceedings, and lemon keeps everybody honest. I am not drinking anything that tastes like it has spent its entire life agreeing with people.

THE OPEN DOOR

The Open Door cocktail with cognac, elderflower liqueur, lemon and Champagne served in a ribbed coupe glass with a lemon twist.

1 oz cognac
½ oz elderflower liqueur
½ oz fresh lemon juice
2 oz chilled brut Champagne or sparkling wine
Lemon twist

Add the cognac, elderflower liqueur and fresh lemon juice to a shaker with ice. Shake briefly, strain into a chilled coupe, and top with Champagne. Express the lemon peel over the glass and place it along the rim.

I serve The Open Door in a ribbed vintage-style coupe. The glass is broad, elegant and just theatrical enough to make Champagne understand that it has been invited somewhere.

I found a set that suits the assignment perfectly. The ribbed detailing gives it a little Art Deco attitude without turning the bar cart into a costume department.

Shop the coupe glasses on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate, I may earn from qualifying purchases.

Then sit down.

Preferably in a perfectly good chair that does not have your name on it.

That, as we have established, is precisely the point.

AND I FILED THE RECEIPTS

That afternoon in Wisconsin stayed with me because I realized I needed more than a clever conclusion. I needed a method. I wanted something I could actually take with me the next time I found myself sitting in a parking lot conducting a full congressional hearing with my own nervous system.

So I created ACCESS WITHOUT ASSIMILATION: A PEPPER SAINT CLAIR FIELD GUIDE.

It goes considerably further than this little dispatch. I built the guide around the questions I wish I had asked myself before I ever reached that winery: What am I actually sensing? What do I know about this place? Why am I here? Am I uncomfortable because something is wrong, or because something is unfamiliar? Am I shrinking? Am I performing? Was I actually unwelcome, or did I arrive expecting to be?

Most importantly, I created The Access Ledger, because memory is a terrible witness once emotion gets involved. The ledger gives me somewhere to record what actually happened, what I assumed beforehand, what I learned, how I was treated and whether I would return. Facts first. Interpretation second. Champagne whenever appropriate.

This isn't a guide to getting into “high society.” God forbid.

It is a field guide for expanding the geography of your life without surrendering yourself at the border.

Because sometimes the room really is wrong for you.

Sometimes you're simply somewhere new.

And I would rather collect enough evidence to know the difference.

ACCESS WITHOUT ASSIMILATION — THE FIELD GUIDE

Filed by Pepper Saint Clair.

 

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.